Posted by: Mon Casiple | September 30, 2007

The ZTE Scandal, Its Implications on GMA Survival

Now that the ZTE scandal has partly unfolded–with Sec. Neri’s “hanging” testimony–there are already glimpses of its eventual direction. It can only go up.

The Neri testimony has two seemingly logical and plausible points: One, that the ZTE broadband deal has for its primary backer Comelec Chairman Benjamin Abalos, Jr; and two, that the President herself knows of Abalos role (particularly in the attempt to bribe Neri with 200 (kilos of fish from the Abalos fishponds–sorry, can’t resist that one).

Neri testified that the President told him not to accept the bribe. He thought that may be sufficient to end the matter, even if it puts Abalos in hot water. However, he refused to elaborate or to testify on other conversations with the President regarding the ZTE matter, citing “executive privilege.”

Of course, this puts the Neri testimony on a continuing downslide thereafter as senators expectedly try to elicit the information behind the “executive privilege.” Many do not believe he told the other half of the truth, may be not even the truth he told–primarily because of his own hypes before the Senate testimony. It is also a glaring inconsistency when he readily volunteered the fact of his talk with the President regarding the Abalos bribe, but not the other talks on the ZTE matter itself.

However, we can already glimpse something from the Neri testimony. One, there is definitely the BIG ONE in terms of information hiding behind the “executive privilege.” Two, there are possibly others–more powerful and far more vulnerable–deeply involved in the ZTE scandal. Three, the ZTE scandal has implications that go to the heart of the survival of the GMA administration and ruling coalition–possibly more than the Garci tapes scandal itself.

Secretary Neri is protecting not only the President but an entire arrangement regarding Chinese investments and loans in the Philippines. The arrangement, I think, stinks to high heavens. It is too early to say but there are certain implications already on Philippine national security, the government’s “special relations” with the United States, Philippine sovereignty and national patrimony, violations of the Constitution, and sectoral concerns.

Senator Miriam Santiago is partly correct when she raised the observation that it is all a “squabble over kickbacks.” After all, at the heart of it all is the purported availability of some $18 billion dollars for Chinese investments and loans for the Philippines–a sum approaching, if not surpassing, the money available during the Marcos one-man rule. Senator Mar Roxas himself said the ZTE deal seems to be a “supply-side” decision–meaning the availability of the Chinese money preceded the project. However, as the ZTE drama unfolds, it is slowly becoming clear that what is at stake is the survival of the GMA administration itself.

Given the situation that she failed to reconcile with the opposition after the 2007 elections, that she still does not have any agreement with any or all of the presidentiables, and that there is the inability (for the present) to force a martial rule, GMA is running a clear risk of going down even before the 2010 term ending. The clock is running out on her, with diminishing influence over events as perceptions increase over her lame-duck presidency. The ruling coalition does not have a viable presidentiable at this time, cannot absorb the pressures, and may disintegrate well before 2010.

The ZTE scandal may well be the Waterloo of the Arroyo presidency.


Responses

  1. [...] ever-impressive Mon Casiple gives his analysis of the whole ZTE deal and its fallout: Neri testified that the President told [...]

    MonC: Indeed, I am flattered to get endorsement from the one and only “Explainer.” I agree, Abalos’ resignation is not a “get out of jail free” card. It is a forced move in face of the certain prospect of an impeachment–a temporary respite in the eye of the storm. Thus, it remains to be seen if the ZTE storm will dissipate or will intensify. The latter prospect will be a nightmare for certain people, not just Abalos.

  2. Great piece.

    Thanks to Sen Miriam Defensor-Santiago on her China blah-blah, it makes one focus more on the Chinese government officials involved in the ZTE NBN contract. If indeed, “..there are possibly others–more powerful and far more vulnerable–deeply involved in the ZTE scandal”, then it should be a no-brainer to figure that some Chinese government officials must have benefited from the kickbacks. An eerie feeling comes to light of the great possibility that kickbacks for certain Chinese government officials were done in the Philippines to avoid the prying eyes of the Chinese government, sparing them from the possibility of getting shot in China.

    MonC: Thanks, Chabeli. Indeed, the Chinese are involved, but I doubt if somebody over there will get shot for the ZTE affair. The Chinese, given their very long experience in civilization, will take the longer view.

  3. mon,

    Great, clear view,
    Has Glue fallen into her Waterloo?

    The China hand is holding GMA by the neck. And it threatens to choke the entire economy as well.

    Dire implications for the economy if ZTE fiasco is mishandled.

    How does GMA stand between Uncle Sam and Ka Mao? How does her standing vis a vis either side factor in on her admin’s survival?

    MonC: I would say GMA has not yet fallen but there is a real possibility she may–if current containment efforts fail. As for the Chinese, I think they know and assume all along there will be controversy. They do not have anything to lose, only their money–and they have a lot of it. But the gains will be enormous: significant influence in an erstwhile US-allied government and country of strategic location, significant source of strategic minerals–possibly including oil and gas, expanded market presence, isolation of Taiwan, and strengthening influence in the local Filipino-Chinese community. There’s little more that it can wish for. Of course, GMA is playing off Uncle Sam and Comrade Mao here.

  4. MonC,

    Is Neri a hero or a heel? I get the feeling that he is deliberately dropping his bombs gradually and very carefully and at planned strategic targets at selected times… for the most damaging impact possible. Strike and counterstrike strategy.

  5. He makes it appear that he won’t implicate Gloria. But he knows he has already done so by claiming executive privilege. He knows that his boss knows she has been logically implicated. Is this part of the game plan?

    He is no longer part of Gloria’s circle of confidants. A pariah to the gang. So why hasn’t he resigned yet ? Am definitely sure it’s not for lack of prospective employers.

  6. Mon,
    From what the Supreme Court said in Senate vs. Ermita, Executive Privilege can only be validly asserted by the President herself, acting perhaps through the Executive Secretary. It is not Neri who asserted it, but the President. Also EP may only be asserted over specific bodies of information, like confidential conversations with Cabinet officers. (I’m sure you know all this.) So you are right to ask why Neri has not resigned, because that is really the only way he can become a whistleblower wtihout breaking the law. Since JDV owns RN, we can only conclude that all involved have realized that, well, all are involved. I don’t think JDV3 is clean, nor is JDV. That is why RN only confirmed what had already been leaked through jarius. Abalos takes the fallout with resignation and everybody else keeps to omerta. Weird thing is, the case filed by Roxas-Aquino doesn’t question the assertion of EP over Neri’s info, unless he told them everything is in those ICC minutes. I think this is as far as it gets, because the High Court can just sit on this forever, or issue another fancy but ambiguous decision, like release the minutes but allow censorship of information that validly is covered by EP, like confidential Cabinet conversations involving diplomatic secrets. I think the discord PDI caused with that story of theirs on Joker may also be the reason the petition is so weak and does not have the whole senate’s backing.

  7. mag sabi na kayo ng totoo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  8. can you pls make me a oration about the zte scandal?
    our topic is about the issue and is lozada a hero or not. tnx

  9. I hope you will have the time to respond to this question.

    Do you think there are hidden sanctions imposed by the Chinese government to the Philippines for cancelling the deal? If yes, what are these? What are the implications of the cancellation of the deal to Philippine China relations?

    Aileen Bacalso


Leave a response

Your response:

Categories